@JohnS Did you adjust your speedometer after the size change? I ask because when using the stock size, my 04 speedometer was always 2 mph fast compared to speeds on the GPS app on my phone. I moved up to
235/55/17 and the indicated speed is still just a hair fast, which is OK by me, since it gives me a small safety factor. That 4% error might have made your
speedo pretty accurate.
@D'Miles Whatever size you choose, take a hard look at the
Michelin CrossClimate series, I put them on my wife's Infiniti and they are great. They were the top-rated all-season tire a year ago, and I caught the $150 rebate for 4 at Costco, so it brought the price in line with other name-brands that had worse performance. This rebate comes around often at the big Tire shops, but if you buy from Costco, be prepared to fight with them over the change in size. I finally had to get
Michelin to send me an email saying that the "upsize" was approved. These will be my choice when my Continentals finally wear/age out.